smudge pots .. fluidline ??

[eye_pr0mise]

are the smudge pots similar to fluidline ??

 

[misswillow]

Yes, they're a similar product. Some people complained the old smudge pots were a bit dryer than f/l. The new ones (Jade, Amethyst, Bronze, Cobalt & Copper) are all absolutely divine, and I much prefer them to f/l. They are smoother, creamier, easier to apply, and much more long lasting

 

[sindais]

dont bother with the old stila smudge pots- they are dry, hard and its almost impossible to get an even line with it

but the new ones are just divine.

 

[neeshie]

i didn't know there were any new ones but i had one in plum that was just awful...dried up really really quickly

 

[Sophia84]

Yeah the old ones suck!! I have brown and it's sooooo dry, little pieces falling out of my eyes when I apply it! But the new ones ara AMAZING!!!! I have Bronze and I'm completely in love with it! Mac doesn't have a color like this!!

 

[midnightlouise]

I have the grey one and I really like it. Not sure if it's new or old...but it's working great and I like it just as well as my fluidliners

 

[Shawna]

Quote:

Originally Posted by misswillow Yes, they're a similar product. Some people complained the old smudge pots were a bit dryer than f/l. The new ones (Jade, Amethyst, Bronze, Cobalt & Copper) are all absolutely divine, and I much prefer them to f/l. They are smoother, creamier, easier to apply, and much more long lasting

Totally agree. I have Jade and I adore it. It is a way nicer texture than my beloved fluidlines. I am dying to get more.

 

[runtagua]

smudgepots

if you smoosh them around a bit, they are fabulous (the older ones). What seems to be dried up, really isn't. Just dig deep.

 

[Cool Kitten]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophia84 I have Bronze and I'm completely in love with it! Mac doesn't have a color like this!!

it's not the same as Rich Ground?

 

[litlaur]

Hmm. I'm not seeing the new shades on Stila's website, and only Copper on Sephora.

Any chance the old colors have been reformulated?

 

[visivo]

God, they are a million times more amazing that fluidline! I like brassy, but it hardly shows up. Same with non-conformist -- good color, but not as bold as stila's eggplant. I swear by grey and black!

 

[Cool Kitten]

Quote:

Originally Posted by visivo God, they are a million times more amazing that fluidline! I like brassy, but it hardly shows up. Same with non-conformist -- good color, but not as bold as stila's eggplant. I swear by grey and black!

hmmm, Non-conformist shows up pretty bright on me, and so does Rich ground. I didn't get brassy because i thought it would be too light.

 

[Cool Kitten]

Quote:

Originally Posted by litlaur Hmm. I'm not seeing the new shades on Stila's website, and only Copper on Sephora.

i think the new ones were all LE.

 

[jinsy]

what a shame they're LE! the old ones are indeed drier but i'm quite ok with them.

how about BB's gel liners? in terms of colours?