Thanks guys! Does MAC have any lip stains? I'm a makeup noob and the only stain I know is Benefit's 'Benetint' (I realize it's a blush but it's supposed to be apply-able to lips too)
Nope. MAC doesn't have any lip stains, but you can emulate the look by using a Matte liptick, blotting it off pretty much off, then putting on a balm or a lip conditioner.
I think that Lady bug will do the job (it'll look more stain-like than chili, which is more opaque) - You can line with Redd lipliner (orangey-red), then apply Lady bug, blot, than apply another layer