sorry im being a board hog , but ...

[PrettyInPink101]

whats a really good pencil eyeliner with awesome staying power?!... bc ive NEVER used black e/l in my life lol.. and i really want 2, ive always used brown.. so i bought a cheap $3 one, just 2 try and i like it alot. but it smudged and make me look like a had dark circles ... maybe theres a good mac pencil ? thanks so much yall !

 

[Kiseki]

If you're looking for a MAC pencil with good staying power, try MAC's Powerpoint in Engraved.

 

[panda0410]

I dont use a lot of MAC liners unless its the softsparkle pencils or the new pencils from Smoke Signals/Blue Storm, but for a straight up liner that works well try the Lancome Waterproof Khol - they're pretty good

 

[blindpassion]

Well it's not really a pencil, but I like the way it applies MUCH more, MACs tecknakohl liner in graphblack. It doesnt smudge like most pencils do, but the color pay off is really great if you put a few layers on, and its GREAT for the waterline. Definitely try it out

its the only one I use.

 

[SparklingWaves]

I use Lancome and Loreal for Black. I heard that Urban Decay makes a long lasting black in the 24/7 eye pencils.

 

[MiCHiE]

Urban Decay's 24/7 in Zero. It's so hard to get off, though.

 

[Kuuipo]

I love MAC's Kohl pencils. I also like Sephora's waterproof pencils. I have tried all the drugstore brands and they don't measure up.

 

[Girl about town]

i got the new kohl power pencil in feline its lovely really nice texture to work with xx