Black Opal foundation and powders are actually better than Black Radiance, could beat many dept store brands. Their eyeshadows are very pigmented, but Black Radiance has the best loose eyeshdows. As for as l/s and l/l it is tie between both lines and for l/g Black Opal is the best (especially the lip liner lacquer duo) I have not tried either lines mascaras or concealers, but Essence magazine reccommends Black Radiance concealers and Black Opal foundation sticks. My only gripe with Black Opal is that it is so expensive to be a drug store brand $8 to $10, but on the other hand many drugstores in my area reduce the price because it does not sell and Wal-mart discontinued the line and sold everything for $1 because of poor sells.