Stila E/K in Topaz just as good as a white liner?

[ButterflyDior77]

Would you say a skin tone color like Topaz , gives the same eye opening effect as a white liner, but not as harsh? Or is it just personal preference?

I just ordered topaz, and would like to know if it is worth it?

 

[trulynicole]

i tried it and it MUCH more natural compared to using a white liner.
topaz is worth it.

 

[ButterflyDior77]

Quote:

Originally Posted by trulynicole i tried it and it MUCH more natural compared to using a white liner. topaz is worth it.

Thanks!

 

[FiestyFemme]

Quote:

Originally Posted by trulynicole i tried it and it MUCH more natural compared to using a white liner. topaz is worth it.

Agree! White liner looks so unnatural & harsh on me, but Topaz just brightens and defines my waterline.

 

[January]

Honestly, I like Stila Topaz, but I prefer Fascinating by MAC (white eyeliner). I thought I would love Topaz, but I don't use it as much as it looks kind of obvious on my waterline. Fascinating just lightens it and it looks more natural on me.

I haven't tried the white Stila E/K yet though.

 

[Sass]

I am NC50 so I'm darker skin tone and I can't wear white, but Topaz works so well! I love it. Opens up my eyes and people can't tell that it's the liner that's doing it. It looks so pretty too.

 

[elektra513]

Quote:

Originally Posted by FiestyFemme Agree! White liner looks so unnatural & harsh on me, but Topaz just brightens and defines my waterline.

Same here. I can totally get away with Topaz in the waterline at the office, lol. White liner, not so much.

 

[angelisagemini]

I love topaz! I have the white one also and don't use it nearly as much, though I have taken to smudging it around my tear duct as a subtle highlight. But on the days where I'm having a no makeup day I just use topaz and mascara and feel pretty without a lot of fuss.

 

[Shadowy Lady]

I love Stila Topaz too. I actually used to use white liner too and found it very harsh. Honestly I think white is harsh on everyone coz nobody's skin is paper white.

I use Topaz pretty much everyday on my waterline

 

[darae]

anything white, even clothes does not look good on me. i always need to wear off-white, ivory so topaz does look more natural on me than white :]

but it's not a MUST-HAVE imo, unless you are the type that always puts liner to brighten your eyes

 

[Twinkle_Twinkle]

It looked weird on me so I swapped it. Maybe I just wasn't applying it correctly though...