stila kitten vs. oasis

[xiahe]

i've seen several pictures of both shadows, and in some pictures they look similar but in others they look rather different. would anyone be able to post a swatch comparing the two? i really like both colors but i don't want to purchase both of them if they both look somewhat similar to each other...

TIA! ♥

 

[Ralphdog]

I'm at work so I can't swatch them for you, but they are very different. Kitten is much more skintoned and shimmery while Oasis is warmer and has a gold glow. I love them both but if you are only going to get one, get Kitten - I think it's my favorite eyeshadow of all time.

BTW - Love your quote, Jimmy Eat World is my favorite band

 

[misswillow]

Kitten is a very shimmery, almost frosty pinky-beige (beautiful colour!) and Oasis is a shimmery peachy-gold. This isn't the best pic - they look more similar here then on

IRL Oasis is warmer and less shimmery, and more peachy, while kitten is a cooler pink-based beige.

http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/kirks1...27.jpg&.src=ph

 

[miss-lilly]

I don't think they are similar, I totally agree with the above decriptions. If you're going to get only one, then go for kitten!
I'll try to swatch them for you if I can figure out how to post pics here

 

[miss_emc]

In terms of shimmer, Kitten is has far more of it compared to Oasis. Like the others said, Kitten is more neutral pink coloured whereas Oasis is more peach and has a gold sheen. I use Kitten far more than I do Oasis.