This is a little complicated and confusing.

knoxydoll

Well-known member
The question :
What would you do in a situation where an old friend with whom you had a falling out is in a really bad relationship. How do you help her out of it when you don't speak at all anymore?

NOTE : This is going to be a long post, there will be cliffs at the end maybe?

The history between us :
There's this girl I used to be very good friend's, Jaime, with that 2 years ago I had a big falling out with because of her boyfriend. I've known her since 1997/98 and we went through middle and high school together. The reason why we had the falling out was because she changed drasticly when seeing her current boyfriend. Changed her values and the way she treated people, so we just stopped talking. She's still 'friends' (I say that loosely and I'll explain why further down) with two of my girlfriends, Karly and Jenn.

NOTE : Everything I hear about her now is pretty much second hand from Karly and Jenn. However I know they wouldn't change her words to make her seem worse in my eyes.

Background on Jaime :
Growing up Jaime was a hottie (she still is), I mean it. She was very confident, very proud of who she was. She dressed very slutty (lots of clevage, lots of short everything, lots of tight), even though she was very conservative when it came to sex, and sexual contact. She just felt pretty dressing that way. She was very popular, and a really good and nice person. She loved pink and white, all shades and everywhere. She once wanted 6 kids... 5 boys, 1 girl. She wants to be a Kindergarten teacher, or low grade school teacher. She's in Uni right now taking some bullshit course that will do her no good.

The summer of grade 11 she started hanging out with some different people boys then who we used to. No big deal we knew most these guys and were friends from grade school; but she wouldn't hang out with her old guy friends anymore, forcing her friends to have out with the new guy friends (this included me). This was okay, weird but okay. Jaime started seeing Sacha during our last year. She fell in 'love'. I still don't believe it's true love but that's just my opinion. I don't really like Sacha, something about him bugs me, and I finally see what it is.

Slowly Sacha started becoming more controlling and weird just in general. He's very insecure and is a lot like his dad. His father was abusive to his mother and very, very controlling. Sacha is pretty much the male succubus, lol. Jaime essentially stopped seeing all of her friends, and getting mad at us because we didn't want Sacha to come to girls nights and stuff like that. This made our relationship worse.

So present time :
Jaime and Sacha are still together. Last summer they bought a cat, together. They don't live together, yet the cat is theirs together. I see so many problems with that but whatever, it's not that important. She told her mother that it was either the cat or a child; she was 18 at the time. At one point she became very dominant over Sacha and things seemed to be getting better, she was returning back to normal. But alas, that didn't happen.

She has made a complete 180 from her self. She thinks she's ugly; She thinks she's fat; She thinks she will never be able to get anyone else; She's become a vegetarian because Sacha is by religion; She's become an uber (ignorant) health freak, but not the healthy way... if that makes any sense; She has very few 'friends'; She won't go anywhere other than work and school without Sacha. He has full control over what she wears and eats. We know he has verbally abused her, and emotionally for sure. We don't know if he has ever physically abused her, but I wouldn't put it past him.

Jaime is 5'4'', weighs probably under 100lbs. She's gorgeous, perfect, pale skin, dark hair, full lips. She can get any man she wants, she has great sex appeal and knew how to use it. She's not a healthy veg; it scares me when I think back to one of my birthday dinners. We went for stirfry, she had 9$ worth of chicken, and that was it. Now she won't touch fast food, or meat of any kind. She won't drink or eat anything that has been in plastic. She doesn't eat cooked vegetables. She essentially doesn't eat. That scares me. She won't go out with us when we go dancing (something she used to love) because Sacha won't come with us, and he won't let her go alone because he's scared she'll cheat on him. She wouldn't but he's stupid. She now wears dark colours (brown, black, navy, grey) and is completely covered. No chance of seeing any skin. It's all loose fitting.
She lost herself.
Karly and Jenn have confronted her about it slightly but she didn't believe them.


This is what is most weird. I feel bad for her and I want to help her get out of this. I want her to realize how bad he is for her. But we don't speak. I see her now and then when we're both at Karly and Jenn's. But Sacha comes with so we can never really confront her about this.

The question again : How do I help her?

CLIFFS : An old friend with whom I've had a falling out is in a really bad relationship and doesn't believe us when we tell her it is. She needs out before it get physically abusive, I'm worried for her.

I hope that wasn't too confusing if it was just ask a question and I'll try to answer better.
 

DevinGirl

Well-known member
This is a really crappy situation. It's nice that there are still people out there who give a crap about one another. IMO the hard fact about this dilemna & countless others like it...is that she's a grown woman who can make her own decisions - bad or good. In my experience (brother w/ drug problems, my mother's insane, the list goes on & on) seeing some hurtful thing that a loved one or just someone you care about...& if they don't agree (that it's harmful or potentially harmful) then that's all there is to it. You can't make someone see something they refuse to or can't. You can talk to her until you're blue in the face, & if she just plain doesn't want to change...she won't. Even if it's in her best interest to pull her head out of her a** & wake up & see the big picture. If I were you I'd just tell her that you're concerned. If she pulls the whole: "We don't talk anymore, why do you care now" speil, just tell her that caring about someone doesn't mean you have to meet some sort of quota, you're just worried. Tell her why. Then let the chips fall where they may. You've said your piece & honestly that's all you can do. The ball is in her court.
 

Beauty Mark

Well-known member
I don't know if you can help her. You could try to meet with her and explain that you're really concerned about her and her health. That's all you can do. She might take the advice, she might not. Being an ex-friend is likely not to be treated so well; when I've tried to help people who haven't liked me, I'm often dismissed.

However, if she is as in bad of shape as you say, it's worth a shot. Maybe it'll give her something to think about.
 

Raerae

Well-known member
Yup, you can't make those decisions for her.

Besides, just because she's changed, doesn't mean that she isn't happy with her new self. You just want your old friend back, and maybe she's just moved past that part of her as a person. These situations are really tuff. Typically it takes the guy really fucking up b4 they change, and even then, it's not always the case.
 

saniyairshad

Well-known member
Hon I think as much as u don't talk to her, yalll did share a history together I know it can be annoying to see her with Sacha, but try calling her on her cellphone at night and having nightly chats with her. I know itll take yall sometime to become what yall were but seriously try getting her to see a counselor for her emotional/verbal abuse and eating problems.. I know she needs u more than anything. It wont hurt to take the first step. PM me if you'd like hon... Good luck!!
th_hug.gif
 

knoxydoll

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Raerae
Yup, you can't make those decisions for her.

Besides, just because she's changed, doesn't mean that she isn't happy with her new self. You just want your old friend back, and maybe she's just moved past that part of her as a person. These situations are really tuff. Typically it takes the guy really fucking up b4 they change, and even then, it's not always the case.


She's really miserable right now. She made the claim that she was going to kill herself, but we know she would never. She too religious and honestly wouldn't be able to inless Sacha did it for her. We know she was just wanting attention. She had surgery on her throat last summer and she's convinced she's dieing from whatever caused her to surgery (she's not btw I've see her parents around and they think she's gone crazy).
Really I could care less if we became friends again. I just don't like to see anyone be abused day in, day out but someone who supposedly loves them. She has no one to turn to. She goes to work, goes home and talks Sacha. She goes to school, Sacha waits outside the lecture hall. She comes to visit her supposed friends, Sacha shows up in ten minutes. I've said it beforeto my friends that if I ever find out he's physically abused her I will hurt him. It's like killing baby animals for no point at all; she's really fragile. I can stand spousely abuse, either way.
She was supposed to come to a movie night with us but came down with the flu and was truly devistated about it (we ended up having a great time doing some random thing that Jaime wouldn't have been up for). I know she wants attention, but I don't know if she wants help. She might come over to Karly and Jenn most often now because school is going to be over soon and if she doesn't it means we can question her a little bit on stuff.
 
Top