Top 10?

[Tsunami Rose]

I'm new to this whole MAC craziness. I was wonder what would your top ten pigments, top ten eyeshadows, top ten liglosses would be? Or even your top 5?

I don't have that many MAC products and just want to get your opinions/reviews so I can make my choices easier!

 

[User49]

Top 5 Pigments

1 Teal
2 Fairy Light
3 Rebel Rock Blue (limt edt collection)
4 Golden Olive
5 Naked

Top Ten Eye Shadows

1 Club
2 Mulch
3 Carbon
4 Aquadisac
5 Deep Truth

Top 5 Lipglosses

1 Bountiful Lustreglass
2 Oyster Girl
3 Foolishly Fab
4 Raquel Welch Tiger one
5 Moon something or other Lip Jelly

To be honest it's hard to make a top five or ten list. And it's all very personal because everyone has different skintones. For example I love love love mulch e/s as it is a great contour for my skintone, but you may prefer one that is darker. But you can't go wrong with some basics like

Carbon Eyeshadow
Bei-jing Shade Stick
Prep and Prime for face
Blue Brown pigment or Club eyeshadow
Smolder Khol Pencil
Pro Lash Mascara

xx

 

[xxManBeaterxx]

Top 5 Pigments

1 Coco
2 Vanilla
3 Cocomotion
4 Apricot pink (I mix this in with some clear lipglass and some reflects glitters and i love it)
5 Gold dusk

Top 5 Eye Shadows

I like neutrals
1 Woodwinked
2 Shale
3 Nylon
4 Satin taupe
5 Jest

Top 5 Blushes (ill do 2 LE and 3 regular line)

1 Fleurry
2 Dont be shy
3 Sunbasque
4 Dollymix
5 Peachykeen

Others i love (random)
1. Studio fix fluid
2. Plushlash mascara
3. Blacktrack fluid line

Top 5 Brushes
1. Depends on what you like but you always need 1 eyeliner brush either 212,208,263, 266.
2. 217
3.182 kabuki
4. 136 for blush its 62 bucks but it lasts for years, and if you buy the 129 another popular face brush its 34 dollars but it is a little prickly
5. 187

..If i could have these things forever i would be happy

 

[bartp]

top 5 pigments
- naked
- pink pearl (mac pro)
- violet
- marine ultra (mac pro)
- teal reflects

top 5 eye shadows
- copperplate
- club
- vex
- vellum
- beauty marked

top 5 lipgloss - lipstick
- plushglass Angel Cream
- 4N lipglass
- Brew lipstick
- Bare slimshine
- Half 'n half, Saint Germain lipstick

top 10 is just too difficult to decide for me too..
a few more firm favorites are :
- prep + prime SPF 50
- mineralize powder
- mac fragrances
- mac beauty powders

 

[Girl about town]

top five lippys
fleshpot (pro)
Angel
russian red
girl about town
melrose mood (heatherette)

eyeshadows

Humid
nylon
moodring (heatherette)
jewel blue
swish

pigments
pink pearl
rebel rock blue
golden olive
sweet sienna
fuchia

blush
pink swoon
dollymix
sweet william
sunbasque
eversun

lipglass
angel cream plushglass
bonus beat (heatherette)
underage
lychee luxe
viva glam 6 se

 

[tendresse]

oh man, threads like these are why I go broke with MAC

 

[KikiB]

Top 5 Pigments
Jardin Aires (a bajillion collections)
Aire-de-Blu (Danse?)
Helium (Balloonacy)
Violet
Mutiny (Naughty Nauticals)

Top 5 Eyeshadows
Crystal Avalanche
Goldmine
Aquadisiac
Moon's Reflection
Stars 'n Rockets

Top 5 Lips
Ms. Fizz Dazzleglass
Funtabulous Dazzleglass
Flash-n-Dash Lipstick (Fafi)
Style Minx lipglass (Heatherette)
Hollywood Nights lipstick (Heatherette)

Top 4 Face
Alpha Girl BP (Heatherette)
Lune Blushcreme (Lure)
Maidenchant Blushcreme (Lure)
Belightful Iridescent powder

 

[wifey806]

I'm kinda new too, so in no particular order:

shadow:
-bisque/kid/era (either one, they're interchangeable for me)

-humid
-stormwatch
-swiss chocolate or soft brown
-yogurt
-mink pink (ok,prolly my #1)
-expensive pink
-shadowy lady
-malt

cheeks:
-ladyblush


pigments:
-don't have any, but if would buy vanilla if I started collecting

Others:
-mineralize skin finish naturals

 

[SMMY]

Top five pigments
Gold dusk
Coco
Coco beach
Your Ladyship
Sweet Sienna

Top five eye shadows
Moth brown
Firespot
French Grey
Waternymph
Terre a Terre from the Corps De Couleur quad.


Top five lipglasses/lipsticks
Queen's Sin
Hollywood Nights
Sockhop
Pink Cabana
Lollipop Loving

 

[panda0410]

Top five pigments
Green frost original - if I was only allowed to keep ONE of my piggies ever this would be the one!
Coco
Subtle
Your Ladyship
Sweet Sienna

Top five eye shadows - I own very few so I will list the best of what I have
Smoking
Showstopper
Black Tied
Beauty Marked
Parrot


Top five lipglasses/lipsticks
Queen's Sin
Strawbaby
Lady Bug
Curiositease
Poppy Hop or Love, Henri - I cant decide which I like better......

 

[darkishstar]

My Top 5/10 Lists
Not ranked in the order I'm listing, they're pretty much an equal top 5 or 10.

Top Five Pigments:
-Electric Coral
-Teal
-Fuchsia
-Golden Olive
-Sweet Sienna

Top 10 Eyeshadows:
-Waternymph
-Earthly Riches MES
-Mi'lady MES
-Naked Lunch
-Parrot
-Black Tied
-Aquadisiac
-Mood Ring from Heatherette Trio 1
-V.I.P from Heatherette Trio 2
-Chrome Yellow

Top 5 Lipsticks
-Hollywood Nights
-Lollipop Loving
-Bombshell
-Queen's Sin
-Girl About Town

Top 10 lipglasses
-Prrr
-Nymphette
-Palatial
-Style Minx
-2N
-Starlet Kiss
-Flashmode
-Red Romp
-Love Rules
-Sock Hop

Top Face:
-Alpha Girl
-Warmed
-Light Flush
-Fix+ (I'm putting this here)

Other things I LOVE:
-Sea Me Shadestick
-Sharkskin Shadestick
-Blacktrack Fluidline
-Delft Paint Pot

 

[purrtykitty]

Here are mine in no particular order...

Top 5 pigments:
Vanilla
Coco
Deep Purple
Lily White
Mauvement
(I'm lemming a bunch more which may end up being favorites)

Top 10 Eyeshadows:
Clue
Neutral Pink
Sunday Best
Satellite Dreams
Woodwinked
Satin Taupe
Springtime Skipper
Blanc Type
Earthly Riches (MES)
Shimmermoss

Top 10 lipglasses/lipsticks:
Fine China l/g
Bare Slimshine
Retrodaze l/s
Prrr l/g
Silly l/g Stain
Early Bloomer l/g
Lollipop Lovin' l/s
Moonshine Lipgelee
Gemshine Lipgelee
Plink l/s

Other Favorites:
Mocha Blush
Fleurry Blush
Glissade MSF
Light Flush MSF
187 Brush

 

[Tsunami Rose]

Thanks you guys!

 

[mocha_queen]

Top 5 Pigments :
Vanilla
Rebel Rock Blue
Fuschia
Chartreuse
Golden Olive

Top 5 Eye shadows :
Deep Truth
Carbon
Passionate
Bitter
Electric Eel

 

[Primula]

Top 10 lip products:
Ample Pink Plushglass
Grenadine Slimshine (love this! It's such a pretty color)
High Tea lipstick
Ruby Woo lipstick
See Sheer lipstick
Sweet & Nice Tendertone
Sweet Tooth Tendertone
Tropic Glow Slimshine
Venetian Lustreglass
Wonderstruck Lustreglass

Top 10 eyeshadows:
B-Rich
Brill
Crystal
Grain
Haunting
Jeweltone
Juxt
Melody
Shroom
Woodwinked

Top six face products:
Coygirl blush
Feeling BPB
Joyous BPB
Lightescapade MSF
Margin blush
Stereo Rose MSF

Other favorites:
Blue Herizon Liquidlast Liner
Greenplay Liquidlast Liner
Haunting Fluidline
Lucky Jade Shadestick
Macroviolet Fluidline
Otherworldly Paint Pot
Painterly Paint Pot
Pink Couture Shadestick
Silverspun Glitter Liner
Taupographic Shadestick

Top seven pigments:
Bell-Bottom Blue
Emerald Green
Royal Flush
Sunpepper
Vanilla
Violet
Your Ladyship

 

[rabideloise]

Top 5 Pigments:
1. Shimmertime
2. Deckchair
3. Coco Beach
4. Gold Stroke
5. Kitchmas

Top 5 Lipsticks
1. Hue
2. Fresco
3. Sophisto
4. Blankety
5. Rocker

Top 5 Eyeshadows
1. Shale
2. Mythology
3. Trax
4. Club
5. B-Rich

Top 5 Lipglass/Lustreglasses
1. Florabundance
2. Wonderstruck
3. Young Spark
4. Viva Glam VI
5. The gold one that came with the 06 holiday set