true must-haves: help me pick!!!

[Sanne]

I made a list of MAC aeyeshadows I don't have (yet), and I would like your opinion about these, give me 5 of your musthaves!

(EDIT: I put number of votes behind eyeshadows)
beautiful iris: 7
Carbon: 5
Nylon: 4
Orange: 4
Sweet lust: 3
Pollen: 3
Deep truth:3
Felt blue: 3
Nocturnelle: 2
Pink freeze: 2
Rice paper: 1
Seedy pearl: 1
Fade: 1
Contrast: 0
Green smoke: 0
White frost: 0
Petalescent: 0

This is my pick:
Beautiful Iris
Carbon
orange
pollen
Fade

 

[singinmys0ng]

I would say

Carbon
Pollen
Orange
Deep Truth
Pink Freeze

 

[glittergoddess27]

Sweet Lust
Beautiful Iris
Nylon
Orange
Felt Blue

 

[mac_obsession]

Pink Freeze
Beautiful Iris
Sweet Lust
Orange
Carbon

 

[Sanne]

great thanks!! I guess I'll put carbon, orange and beautiful iris on my list

Anyone else??

 

[Juneplum]

omg!

deep truth (LOVE THIS)
beautiful iris
fade
nocturnelle
felt blue

 

[laceymeow]

i know it's only 2, but i say definitely nylon and deep truth.

 

[Oonie]

I'll agree with Carbon, which I was using as liner along with Black Tied, until the Fluidliner came out.

Another one for me is Humid.

 

[Bianca]

I love Beautiful Iris!

 

[MAC_Whore]

Edit

 

[Sanne]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oonie I'll agree with Carbon, which I was using as liner along with Black Tied, until the Fluidliner came out. Another one for me is Humid.

I allready have black tied and humid, I made a list of e/s that I didn't have!! But you're right humid and black tied are amazing!!!

MACwhore, you're not making it much easier LOL

but thanks for your input :loveya:

 

[midnightlouise]

For me it would be:
Nylon
Pollen
Rice paper
Seedy pearl
Sweet lust

 

[FacesbyNiki]

Nocturnelle.. I love this purple..

 

[Brianne]

Definitely Seedy Pearl and Beautiful Iris.

I love using Seedy Pearl with the Madame B eyeshadows as a change from the pink shade.

 

[Sanne]

great thanks!

 

[mspixieears]

I've only got 2 also - Beautiful Iris (absolute must-have) and Felt Blue (don't have it yet, so by recommending it to you, I'm fulfilling my lust for it! haha!).

I found Seedy Pearl grossly difficult to wear but it would be more flattering on lighter skintones.

 

[faithhopelove24]

carbon
seedy pearl
orange
nylon
haux ( i know it's not on your list but i like it alot!!)

 

[Sanne]

faithhopelove, don't you think that Haux isn't a bit to dark for me? I'm NW25, blond hair.

I edited my list again, thanks girls!!!

I'm going may 1th to amsterdam, I'm planning on buying a new palette (my fourth!!! whoohoo!)
I think I know how to fill it now, but all inputs are still welcome!!!
xxx

 

[faithhopelove24]

no, I don't think so, I think Haux is an exellent crease color and a softer alternative to Sketch, Embark or Carbon But I guess the only way to know is to try it out. Good luck on making your new pallate

 

[eyeshadowfreak]

Have to jump in about Haux.

I'm an NW15, dark hair and I LOVE Haux as a crease color. Definitely not too dark.