I'm not sure about the "cakey up close" look, but I am a stage performer (Vegas & on tour all over the Country) and I use Estee Lauder Double Wear Foundation or Temptu Airbrush makeup. Both over a really good makeup primer. I use the makeup primer by Arbonne, but there are lots of options out there. I think any foundation will look "cakey" if it is over applied. I don't have that look, but you can definitely tell I'm wearing a lot of makeup up close. If they are young girls and they are at competitions, I know when I did that when I was younger, no one had a clue how to do our makeup so they just piled it on. I think they used some drugstore brand foundation in a stick form. But you can get a good stage face without looking gross up close!