WHAT?! NOT HER!

[melozburngr]

Ok, so Im a little upset that Carrie won on American Idol....and not just cuz I lost a bet with my bf..

anyone else? (a little jealous they got Mustangs, too!!! lucky bastards, those things are hot!)

 

[allie02044]

i really wanted her to win, but for some reason i feel REALLY sad for Bo!! even though i wanted carrie to win, I thought Bo would win!!!! i think i really like the single shes gonna have out too!

 

[Isabel]

I was routing for Carrie and thought BO was going to win the whole time.

 

[melozburngr]

I dunno- I didnt like Carrie from the start- yeah her voice is relatively pleasant, but she was out of tune on most higher octave notes, and when out of her genre (country) she seemed to falter a bit... and for me? BORING.

Bo had energy, was so fun to watch, awesome to listen to, etc... and I can't wait for that record thats gonna make with Clive Davis to come out

 

[nphernetton]

I wanted Bo to win...I was disappointed, but its ok, he's amazing, he'll be big time either way. He has such great stage presence that he doesnt need "american idol winner" on his resume...

 

[MxAxC-_ATTACK]

it doesnt matter they are both gonna get record deals anyways.

 

[Alexa]

Quote:

Originally Posted by MxAxC-_ATTACK it doesnt matter they are both gonna get record deals anyways.

yup.. i was so excited she won, she deserved it the most. when they said her name i screamed so loud my parents came running...heh oops. but honestly, theyre both gonna make it big, its just the title of 'american idol' that she won. theyre both at the same success level right now

 

[Eye<3Colour]

i think they both were great. i wish bo would of won tho. he was a great entertainer. carrie reminds me of kelly clarkson, which isn't a bad thing. but i was hoping bo would win!!

 

[Shoe Crazy]

I am VERY upset about Carrie winning! Bo was a real entertainer/performer...all Carrie does and get on the stage and sing she has no stage presence and she is SOOO BORING!!!

Vocally she was better than Bo but I really don't think she should have won. I think Bo will do just fine I actually think he got the better deal because she will have to make a typical "American Idol" record while Bo while be able to make any kind of record he so pleases.

 

[toropcheh]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shoe Crazy I think Bo will do just fine I actually think he got the better deal because she will have to make a typical "American Idol" record while Bo while be able to make any kind of record he so pleases.

My sentiments EXACTLY. This is what I've been saying from the beginning. lol

 

[singinmys0ng]

i feel the same way..i wanted them both to win. BUT I think Bo should have won because he is so diffrent and he has so much more stage prenecse. Carrie's voice is good..but imo, Bo's is so much better!

 

[melozburngr]

good point- the AI records kinda suck

Bo will be able to make an awesome record on his own..

I just cant wait to buy it!

 

[SugarAsh182]

I personally don't really like either one of them... so I didn't even watch! Carrie is really cute though and both of them have great voices IMO!

I wanted Mario Vasquez (spelling? lol) to win! The Justin Timberlake lookalike! Such a great voice! I was sooo upset when he dropped out! I think he would have won if he would have stayed in!

 

[misslexa]

im glad... they will both do well though! but i like carried just a lil bit more

 

[user2]

I've just seen her in the news over here...eek...she looks exactly like Kelly Clarkson...but Bo does too...*g*

 

[Juneplum]

ugh... she's kills me with her boring self.. i'm not worried about bo tho... he'll get a record deal and will end up being more popular.. just like clay overshadowed ruben...

 

[PnkCosmo]

Quote:

Originally Posted by toropcheh Quote: Originally Posted by Shoe Crazy I think Bo will do just fine I actually think he got the better deal because she will have to make a typical "American Idol" record while Bo while be able to make any kind of record he so pleases. My sentiments EXACTLY. This is what I've been saying from the beginning. lol

ITA...those two "original songs" that Bo & Carrie had to sing were sooooo lame!! I'm actually really glad that Bo didn't win, b/c at least now he doesn't have to have one of those lame-ass songs as his first single.

I can't wait to hear his record and the original songs he's already written.