When i had a massive tan NC42ish global glow hardly showed up on me, it was mainly a golden highlight color with minimal shimmer.
Global Glow is a gorgeous golden bronze color with gold pearl, its lighter than shooting star. (I loved it) --I think you should go with this color
Shooting Star is pretty dark i think you need to apply it with a light hand. Its a very dark golden brown.
Personally my favorite mac MSF bronzer is So Ceylon