Still looking for my HG product, but for now I use the Body Shop Aloe Soothing Night Cream (and their respective Day Cream during the day.) I have dry/sensitive skin and my skin drinks it up! It's a little pricey ...$20 for 1.7 oz, but I don't glob it on. Just dab a dot on my forehead, cheeks, nose and a little on my chin/neck area and it's sufficient enough.
Plus it only has a 1 on the EWG Skin Deep database, so it makes me feel good I'm not putting too much gunk on my face!
You can check it out here: http://www.thebodyshop-usa.com/skin-care/skin-care-best-sellers/aloe-soothing-night-cream.aspx
I don't know about body lotions so I'll be curious to read about everyone else's thoughts ... I was using Cerave but I'm not to happy it has parabens in it so I'm looking for a switch.