Got my glosses and took some pics for all of you!
First, my thoughts:
Overall Formula: These do tingle a tiny bit on the lips - almost a peppermint-like sensation, similar to but not as strong as the BE Buxom glosses. I really enjoy it, but I know some of you may not like that so much. They smell a little different than the regular MAC glosses - still a hint of Vanilla, but this one is a different kind of sweet. I really can't put my finger on it. Lou mentioned coconut, and I detect it a bit, but I'm still thinking of something else. Again, I enjoy it, but others may not.
Bubble Tea: A beautiful peachy-brown nude with the slightest hint of shimmer that is barely noticeable on the lips (think like the Kissable Lip Colours). Very sheer and pretty, and gorgeous for me as a MLBB neutral gloss. I think this could go really well over Gaga 2, for those of you who were not a fan of the brown gloss. Sorry I don't own it to compare, yet! I'm excited for this one with The Faerie Glen, Innocence, Beware and Touch.
Fashion Fanatic: A sheer peachy-pink colour with fine shimmer. This colour looks close to Bubble Tea on the lips, except a hint warmer, brighter and more shimmery. I think it will be beautiful over Playing Koi, and could be really pretty over shades like Peachstock and Cut a Caper! It would also be pretty over some of the nude/browns I mentioned above, I think
Girl
Boy: A creamy pale blue-based pink with no shimmer. This is the most pigmented shade of the bunch. It is very light and pretty, and still somewhat sheer. Almost milky looking. I did find this one settled into some fine lines just a touch, so it may be better over a liner or lipstick, but it is super pretty. Although I don't normally pull off blue-based too well, this colour was still really pretty on me!
This could help to make St. Germain more wearable for some of us!
Pics:
Nude lips
Bubble Tea
Fashion Fanatic
Girl
Boy
Bottom to top: Bubble Tea, Fashion Fanatic, Girl
Boy
Hand Swatches in Shade, L-R: Bubble Tea, Fashion Fanatic, Girl
Boy
Hand Swatches in Sunlight, L-R: Bubble Tea, Fashion Fanatic, Girl
Boy
Overall, I'm really pleased with these - I don't find them too sticky (not as sticky as the regular lipglasses), I like the tingling feeling, I like the smell (although I don't smell much when I'm wearing them on my lips), and I like the colours. BT and FF are fairly sheer, and may be dupeable from things in your stash. For me and my collection, they were unique, so I was happy. Girl
Boy is the most pigmented and unique of the shades I bought, especially because there is no shimmer. It would be pretty over just about any pink lipstick, I'd imagine - maybe even VG Gaga 1 or Snob!
HTH
P.S. Yes, I'm alive again! Just back to a very busy schedule with school :S