Alrighty, Caramel is too light for me. Not incredibly light, but just enough to be a little ashy, and I don't like that at all. Contrary to what I've heard, it does NOT oxidize.
Stick foundation is AMAZING. Worth every penny.
Liquid foundation leaves much to be desired. Sheer to medium coverage... can streak if you're not careful. Formula is thin... not rich or dense like ... say Guerlain Parure Anything or Chanel Perfection Lumiere.
Cream/Liquid Foundation brush is FABULOUS. Doesn't eat the product and just 'diffuses' it over the skin. Worth every penny.
Both foundations are going back for a color that better suits my skin tone... and the liquid foundation may just end up staying there. I didn't need it anyway.