MAC Heavenly creature discussion

rockin

Well-known member
Temptalia tweeted that she ordered one of everything, and will drop everything and get swatching just as soon as they arrive
 

Richelle83

Well-known member
Universal Appeal, Magnetic Attraction, Earthly

I don't have dupes for these! UA is purple, may not show it here though. I don't know what Earthly is lol




Shimmery/glittery yes, gritty no!!
 

NinaHouston

Well-known member
And I was referring to the fact that there are still a good amount of people on here constantly making nasty remarks about her, and anytime I point out the fact that she did nothing wrong to anybody, I just get attitudes in return or no response at all but meh...I still don't understand hating somebody who never did anything wrong to you.
I personally dislike how passive-aggresive she can be whenever someone makes a comment that isnt to her liking on her site. I dont hate her, but it just turned me off from reading her blog.

I also feel like she is biased against drugstore/lower end products. Case in point, she gave a Revlon Lip Butter a low rating because it didnt last that long on her lips (but when does a gloss last more than an a couple of hours anyway), but gave a Bobbi Brown Lip Treatment thats similar to the Revlon Lip Butter a much higher rating. Is it because its a more expensive product? I have no idea, I just personally find it strange that two similar products get totally different ratings.

I think her rating system is overly scientific, to the point that its nitpicky. This is off topic in this post, I know. I just have to reply because you said you get "no responses at all". Well, here's one.
 

MACina

Well-known member
th_drool.gif
.......soooooo gorgeous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Not the prettiest pic!

 

liesierre

Well-known member
Temptalia tweeted that she ordered one of everything, and will drop everything and get swatching just as soon as they arrive
lol...well by then I'll probably have everything in my hot little hands...(except the MES, anyway)

...okay so in my big sasquatch man-hands, i meant.
 

CartoonChic

Well-known member
Is Magnetic Attraction close to Mythical? I wasn't even considering Earthly until now. Maybe it's a silver taupe?

Universal Appeal, Magnetic Attraction, Earthly

I don't have dupes for these! UA is purple, may not show it here though. I don't know what Earthly is lol




Shimmery/glittery yes, gritty no!!
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
I personally dislike how passive-aggresive she can be whenever someone makes a comment that isnt to her liking on her site. I dont hate her, but it just turned me off from reading her blog.

I also feel like she is biased against drugstore/lower end products. Case in point, she gave a Revlon Lip Butter a low rating because it didnt last that long on her lips (but when does a gloss last more than an a couple of hours anyway), but gave a Bobbi Brown Lip Treatment thats similar to the Revlon Lip Butter a much higher rating. Is it because its a more expensive product? I have no idea, I just personally find it strange that two similar products get totally different ratings.

I think her rating system is overly scientific, to the point that its nitpicky. This is off topic in this post, I know. I just have to reply because you said you get "no responses at all". Well, here's one.
ITA with most of what you said. And that's all I'm gonna say regarding this...
whistle.gif
But I do appreciate her work of course, her photos are the best out there.
 

PixieDancer

Well-known member
Universal Appeal, Magnetic Attraction, Earthly

I don't have dupes for these! UA is purple, may not show it here though. I don't know what Earthly is lol




Shimmery/glittery yes, gritty no!!
Can't tell for certain, but your swatch of earthly looks sort of like Modern Pewter.. It has a green tinge to it on my computer screen.

Thanks for these swatches doll! You are awesome!!
 
Top