I can't compare the Loreal Infallible Eyeshadows to these since they aren't available yet on MAC Pro, but the Loreal Infallible shadows are fantastic on their own merit! I have 9 of them now, and I will probably get more. And I'm not usually a drugstore girl either. But if something is good, it's good. It doesn't always have to cost more to be a better product. If these EC shadows are anything like the Loreal ones, I'll be happy to pass on as many of these as I can dupe with the Loreal shades. At 1/2 the price of the MAC ones (and you can always find them B1G1 50% off!) they are a steal!! I just ordered 5 from ULTA during their Friends & Family 20% off sale, so I got the 20% off PLUS 2 of the shades were on sale for only $3.99!
And if these ARE like Loreal shadows and you love them... check out the Loreal line for more shades! They have greens, purples, golds, taupes, pinks, even a GORGEOUS teal (Endless Sea)!
As soon as I get a couple of these EC shadows, I'll let you know how they compare to the Loreal Infallibles... Fingers Crossed!