MAC By Request discussion

[Corally]

I would love to see some more swatches of Moxie!

 

[mousygiggles]

Ha! How did they get this wrong when the shade was just released a year ago?!

NO doubt!!!! I mean Runway Red was closer in repromote and it was different too. I wish they would just rename them!

 

[OhSoJaded]

i got my box yesterday

Thanks!

I was still washy washy on CYY and didn't order b/c I thought it was still the bright neon pink from Quite Cute. After looking at Richelle's swatches, I'm kicking myself for not putting it in my cart! While it's still bright (and gorgeous), I think the new formula might work a tad better with my skin tone.

Ah, well. Here's to hoping they restock when the e/s are available!

 

[mousygiggles]

your not going to use 6 lipsticks, it will come BACK OUT its just straight hoarding

i just feel bad for the ladies that probably voted everyday that didnt get a chance to order
If it doesnt look right on me, i will gladly sell to one of you ladies for same mac price

That sucks. I have went through 1.5 of the original and hadn't worn it in months so I swapped my last backup of the original. I got 2 of this "new" CYY. I just hope I love it because now I am scared to use my original ever again.

 

[Jenrbelt]

Why am I so OCD! Just because I bought another lipstick, now I feel like I need another gloss, and two eyeshadows so everything is even...it never ends!

 

[honey on boost]

are you not able to use the code "winner" for free shipping??? it doesn't expire until after the e/s come out!

the promo code doesn't work on pro accounts

 

[Spikesmom]

My guess is improving the formula may have affected the color a little bit.

Ha! How did they get this wrong when the shade was just released a year ago?!

 

[andabri]

You guys, I tried on Moxie, and went, I KNOW I have seen this before.

Moxie on the Left, Guerlain Liu Rouge Automatique on the right.



The difference, Moxie is matte, and Guerlain has shine. In the picture the Guerlain looks darker because of the shine, but when you blot it down, it is EXACTLY the same. Like I have never seen a dupe so close in my life.

 

[mousygiggles]

Check out these swatches. May help some.


http://giles22-atl.livejournal.com/18155.html

My Pink Friday and Melrose Mood look nothing like this. At least I don't think they do.

 

[Copperhead]

your not going to use 6 lipsticks, it will come BACK OUT its just straight hoarding

i just feel bad for the ladies that probably voted everyday that didnt get a chance to order
If it doesnt look right on me, i will gladly sell to one of you ladies for same mac price

They come BACK OUT but they're very rarely THE SAME. I'll bet anybody that got like 4 or 5 of the original CYY are happy they did right now. The new one is still very nice but all it takes is a smidgen to throw the shade off.

 

[Knope2012]

Has anyone compared Moxie to Impassioned? I'm curious if they are close.

 

[mousygiggles]

Has anyone compared Moxie to Impassioned? I'm curious if they are close.

I think Impassioned is more pink. IDK though. I am questiong my color comparing abilities today.

 

[Babylard]

Ha! How did they get this wrong when the shade was just released a year ago?!

My exact thoughts!!! LOL The difference is quite drastic for me. I don't want a darker CYY >_<

 

[KMQE716]

i bought 2 extras of CYY but i gave one to someone who missed out and sold another to a girl who also missed out, for the same price.

Im not feeling the CYY hype actually I'm not feeling any of them anymore than the other, i almost feel like Moxie is a dark skin Quick Sizzle.

Rocker...meh...i feel like it's bleeding. Good news is i have had it on since 11 and it still looks the same!

 

[OhSoJaded]

i bought 2 extras of CYY but i gave one to someone who missed out and sold another to a girl who also missed out, for the same price.

Im not feeling the CYY hype actually I'm not feeling any of them anymore than the other, i almost feel like Moxie is a dark skin Quick Sizzle.

Rocker...meh...i feel like it's bleeding. Good news is i have had it on since 11 and it still looks the same!

If you decide it's really not for you, at least it's a hot ticket item. You'll be able to swap it out w/ no problems

 

[Knope2012]

http://www.temptalia.com/swatch-gallery?color=Fuchsia&action=Sort&type=156&brand=11

Maybe someone's eyes are better then mine. Here, Moxie looks like a matte Impassioned. Does it look that way to anyone else?

 

[aradhana]

Would anyone be willing to cp a moxie for me? It seems to not have been restocked in canada...

 

[Copperhead]

Maybe we're all going to have to go buy the Stila dupe for CYY. MAC, you do this to yourself!

Or maybe NYX's Shocking Pink Matte? I don't know how that one compares but it looks to be close.

 

[nudibelle]

They come BACK OUT but they're very rarely THE SAME. I'll bet anybody that got like 4 or 5 of the original CYY are happy they did right now. The new one is still very nice but all it takes is a smidgen to throw the shade off.

4 or 5 of original
and then bought 4 or 5 of new one thinking its just like original

thats a whooooollleeee lotta candy!

i just feel sad for ppl that missed out that never even had original
spread the candy love all im saying

 

[Knope2012]

I think Impassioned is more pink. IDK though. I am questiong my color comparing abilities today.

Thanks! I'm on the fence about it and I don't want to miss out.