That can definitely happen with tempting as it's a lustre. The others are VPs, but can swatch patchy sometimes with a qtip if that's what you used. Finger swatching plays a big role in the texture of Powder testers. But tempting is sooo
i wear it all the time in the summer for a shimmery smokey bronze look! PD and SV are gorgeous with green eyes, but are great with all colours. Of the two i prefer SV. KD is ok. Nothing that i think is a must have. If you're looking for a darker grey i suggest print or typographic, depending on how dark you wanna go.