I tried the Ponds a while back and forget why I didn't like them. Maybe I'll have to grab a sample pk. of them. The MAC ones are just getting so expensive. When you break down the per wipe price, it makes you cringe! I haven't tried the Neutrogena ones yet, so I'll watch for a deal on those and grab some.I've been using Ponds wipes because they're cheap and I can normally get a great sale for them at Ulta. They're effective at removing my makeup, but I find them drying to my skin. They also tend to dry out in the package as they start to get low. I bought a package of MAC wipes at a CCO just to try out. I like that they seemed more moisturizing compared to the Ponds wipes, but now I find them to be greasy. I still like them better than Ponds.
However, I recently purchased Neutrogena makeup wipes from Ulta. I find them comparable to MAC wipes. I opted for the hard container. I like that it keeps the wipes moist. I'll buy refills in the plastic packaging and will continue to reuse the hard case. I can also get them on sale at Ulta.
Appreciate your response!