I haven't read through this whole thread, but has anyone noticed any similarities here? The formula is different, but the colors are similar, especially Clearwater.
In each swatch photo the pp is on the right and I took pics with flash and without. I ended up not taking pics of Perky because on my hand the palette shadow was way lighter. Very similar, just several shades lighter.
The palette shadows are much creamier and have more slip. When I was removing them with wipes I really had to rub to get the pp's off, but the cream shadows came right off.
Tailor Grey...
Clearwater...