Have you posted Sir Didymus pictures, because you know we want to see!
Hahaha - that must have been some tasty burger.
Subverted is my favorite of the four too, but they're all just so amazing. The frost finish they have is spectacular - it makes your lips look so moist and full and dimensional, which is so important with such dark colors.
I was relieved to hear that the black will be matte, rather than retro matte for the reasons you're saying. I do really like the retro matte formula that's been busting out all over, but I've got to think through the right blush and eye makeup when I wear them, or just go really simple and only wear the lipsticks on their own with nothing else. If MAC does a Punk Couture style collection next year, but gives everything that Nudes & Metallics frost, I am going to be going ten times more bananas than I already am over this one!