Exactly! I have all the PPs with the exception of the silver one, so I'm pretty set on bases. No need to buy liners to use as bases unless you don't have a base that colour already.
I've stopped buying the glittery ones too. I never did get the olive one from DN. I'll only buy them if they're matte and i can use em as a liner.
Funnily enough, that's the third of my three. I use it quite a bit on days when I want a bit of definition but not a super obvious liner. Kinda the way I use UD Mushroom (which is one of my faves)
I need something to replace my Avenue f/l. I def don't need anymore bases.
If you're trying to be conservative about how much you buy, go check it out in person first. You'll easily be able to see if this is something you will go bananas about or not. I know I sure had an immediate response to it….It's totally dark enough for the upper lash line, if you're not planning on wearing false lashes or strong eyeshadow along with it…at least for fairer skins. Then, you have to take into account that the shade is a smashing blend of brown and purple that will look AMAZE-BALLS smudged on the lower lash line or all around the eye, including on deeper skin tones. That way will create just the perfect shadowy look, without getting all smoked out. Just an amazing near-neutral, that's better than a plain neutral all around.
Can you tell I'm crazy excited for it?
Quote: Originally Posted by jennyap
I know, but I'm trying to be semi sensible. 2 of the 3 f/ls I own are at least vaguely brown/purple.
Stop it!!
There ya go, I only use these as liners, so pretty as it is I don't need it. Right?
This is the only item I was planning to get. Seems so close to MAC Twig which I wear every other day. Looks like a skip.
Thanks for sharing! I wasn't interested in any of the lipglasses but this looks like it will pair great with that caramel nude lipstick! (Sensual sparks?)
When I saw the swatch, it jumped out at me like a magical makeup unicorn! 
I need morning rose lipstick. I've been really I to these soft colors lately
Hmmm. Both the colour description and my swatch have shimmerI'll have to say, I've been moving away from black liner for a while, at least since this past year. I've been LOVING a look with a mid-tone liner like Midnight Snack or Added Goodness, or lately Deliciously Rich, where I still wing it out and use a very neutral shadow along with it that's slightly warmer in tone, then just use plenty of black mascara on the upper lashes. I pair it with a strong lip like FOD! This eye look is nice with a more enhanced blush, like Ripe For Love or Blazingly Haute, and keep the lips nearly bare, with just some balm. It's a punchy look, but very soft compared to the more 60's retro of black liner. The glitter or shimmer in something like Deliciously Rich or Stares & Speculations works on the upper lid in that context very well (although if I add shadow, I tend to stick to something more matte or with slight sheen). However, It's Physical is a bit darker than stuff like Added Goodness, S&S, etc. plus it's totally matte - no shimmer or glitter at all. So that's exciting!! It's totally dark enough for the upper lash line, if you're not planning on wearing false lashes or strong eyeshadow along with it…at least for fairer skins. Then, you have to take into account that the shade is a smashing blend of brown and purple that will look AMAZE-BALLS smudged on the lower lash line or all around the eye, including on deeper skin tones. That way will create just the perfect shadowy look, without getting all smoked out. Just an amazing near-neutral, that's better than a plain neutral all around. Can you tell I'm crazy excited for it?
weird. I'll have to check it out again in person. Either way it's definitely a stunning colour!
They're a bit dark, but they're what i have. Sorry, no autoerotique blush swatch
thank you so much!!
Thank you very much for sharing, Erin
Ahhh thank you for swatches! Much love!They're a bit dark, but they're what i have. Sorry, no autoerotique blush swatchCC, Supposed to be CI, but i think SS was swatched by accident instead, MR, SSAQR, SK, HB, OMD, OANF, SH, SD, PL, AAAD, PM
Thank you soooo much @erine1881
