My hubby got me phresh out and cockiness.... I didn't want either but I can make the eyeshadow work. Especially since I find it cute he got it for me. Cockiness however will be going back.
I kinda of like Phresh Out. I don't have too many glittery e/s (esp. since I have been phazing out my Urban Decay stash). The glitters do have the fall out of doom though, so it will be saved for a night out, holiday party or other places where excessive glitter won't be too out of place. Only 2 of the colors are real glittery, the other 3 are just metallic and shimmery. I am contemplating the other quad as well. I do like Cockiness layered just above a black eyeliner. It takes some work to get it to show up but it isn't too much effort. Not like the effort of getting TTT to apply smoothly. Contemplating a back up, actually...
If they ever restock, I will get the other palette, RRW in white and gold packaging, and a Cockiness BU. I really like PP liner too, but won't use it as much. They are both better layered as has been recommended here IMHO. Maybe a restock will magically appear like a Christmas miracle with the upcoming launches of the Huggables, MN, and PC?