So I got my lippies and they are definitely different and unlike anything I have which is what I wanted. By starlight looks nothing like heroine. I love heroine but I'm glad it's not a dupe on me. BS is much, much darker. I really like it but it's extremely stiff. Space cake pulls more blue than grey on me. My 3 year old son loved it and my husband thought I looked like a deranged clown, lol. Oh well, like he said, his opinion doesn't matter because he's not the one wearing it. Damn right! I've trained him well