Thats my biggest worry wit unsealed drugstore products!!! I was excited 8 months ago when i seen NYX at Target, but i could see that almost all the lipsticks had been opened and swatched or what not they need to do inventory and not count those cuz they will sit there forever!!! wit the matte lip creams there is no way to really tell, i vowed to never buy anything thats not sealed again from a drugstore, or ulta icky. I want to try the brow gels so bad!!! I hated the first round lipstick i got Stella. Its gritty feeling on me like someone mixed pigment in vaseline. so when they had the 40% off sale i only ordered one lipstick, a butter lipstick in Hot Tamale. Its pure LOVE!! SO glad to like it. Now want to try a Matte and a Black Label. Im scared to buy a round one again. Got mostly lip liners. Purple Rain, Orange, Peek A Boo Nude, and Soft Brown. I should swatch them all for u guys!! Oh and Aqua Gloss in Paint The Town omg i love that one too. Oh and the best thing i got was a cream blush in Glow OMG i have been using it a lot and i have hundreds of way more expensive blushes so im VERY impressed i must say!!!!