MAC x Rocky Horror Picture Show Collection (Oct 2, 2014)

allthingsglam

Well-known member
Thank you ladies! I must say, I think it is a tough call between FnF and Strange Journey.  FnF definitely looks more berry in person.  It's funny, because Oblivion was the one I felt I needed, and SJ was an impulse. Funny how it works!
I love love them both but Sj is stunning
 

Sweetyellow

Well-known member
They are a creamy matte finish. I tend to blot my lips to make it resemble more of a true matte. SJ is ok. I prefer my reds a bit darker. I am not a big orange-red person. You may like it. Don't give up hop just yet. I will try it again with a liner and maybe even a full face. I may change my mind but I doubt it. Keep me posted on your thoughts after your shipment arrives.
Good to hear. I really like this new matte reformulation. My lips tend to be a little dry so these new matte's are more forgiving. Even more excited now!

Oh and oddly enough I don't own any red-orange lipsticks. I wanted to buy Morange, Lady Danger, and all the other MAC orange-y red lipsticks but haven't gotten around to it with all these limited edition collections.

What lipliner are you thinking of btw?
 

Mizani

Well-known member
I'm back from a mini sabbatical. I had to relax, get some REST, get things done. Got to get prepped to stalk tonight for the Mattes. UGH! I will have to venture to the mall EARLY tomorrow to stand in line Riri style to get FnF which is what I did NOT want to do, especially since I will also be stalking the mattes so here's hoping that collection actually launches online before 8:30 my time.

In the meantime, I guess the positive is I get to see more swatches of FnF to see if it is worth it! :)

Sadly, a part of me will want to get it still anyways since I have invested soooo much time into stalking in the first place. Hate to see that all go for naught, even if I barely wear the color. You fellow MAC addicts understand!
lol.gif
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
That's disappointing that it's a different finish than what people thought they were getting.
There hasn't been a new Sheertone Shimmer in ages, so I guess it was too good to be true.
sigh.gif
Although AI is a Frost as well and it's a really nice finish and not as frosty as expected, it makes me wonder if it's really necessary to own both.
 

Sweetyellow

Well-known member
Quote: Originally Posted by Dolly Snow
Seems that way
ssad.gif



I'm so relieved. I would've had no use for two blushes with the same formula and very similar colors. Do you have Animal Instincts?
 

Vineetha

Well-known member
That's disappointing that it's a different finish than what poeple thought they were getting.
There hasn't been a new Sheertone Shimmer in ages, so I guess it was too good to be true.
sigh.gif
Although AI is a Frost as well and it's a really nice finish and not as frosty as expected, it makes me wonder if it's really necessary to own both.
It isnt overly shimmer, kinda close to AI finish tbh. I think both are gonna look pretty much the same.
Oh and I made a call to the CS : Reply: "Sheertone Shimmer & Frost are the same finish". Yeah really!
sigh.gif
 

Sweetyellow

Well-known member
Quote: Originally Posted by Vineetha
Oh and I made a call to the CS : Reply: "Sheertone Shimmer & Frost are the same finish". Yeah really!
sigh.gif



lmao.gif
 

Mizani

Well-known member
It isnt overly shimmer, kinda close to AI finish tbh. I think both are gonna look pretty much the same.
Oh and I made a call to the CS : Reply: "Sheertone Shimmer & Frost are the same finish". Yeah really!
sigh.gif
WHAT? If that's the case, why have two separate names for them? Aren't sheertones a more sheered down version of a frost sometimes? If so then they are not the same, hence two different names. SMH
 

allthingsglam

Well-known member
Someone had mention in here that the blush was a simmertone whatever that is lol I hate simmer too but for some reason I ordered it anyways I'm hoping this one is beautiful and less shimmery
 
Top