Makeup Geek Eyeshadow

nt234

Well-known member
Flamethrower on the lid, Caitlin Rose bottom lash line, and In the spotlight in the inner corner.  Flamethrower, in the spotlight, caitlin rose and showtime Caitlin Rose is not a smooth shadow, it's actually... pretty bad lol I don't think I'll be using it again. The others remind me of Stila magnificent shadows or whatever they are called, but easier to use and not creasy. They look pretty stunning in person. Also liner doesn't go on as smooth on top of them, so sorry for my choppy liner.  What do u guys think?
Love that look!
 

tirurit

Well-known member


Flamethrower on the lid, Caitlin Rose bottom lash line, and In the spotlight in the inner corner.


Flamethrower, in the spotlight, caitlin rose and showtime

Caitlin Rose is not a smooth shadow, it's actually... pretty bad lol I don't think I'll be using it again.
The others remind me of Stila magnificent shadows or whatever they are called, but easier to use and not creasy.
They look pretty stunning in person. Also liner doesn't go on as smooth on top of them, so sorry for my choppy liner.

What do u guys think?
Choppy liner?! I will not show you mine
girlhaha.gif


They look really nice. From the swatch caitlin rose looks a bit more crumbly but nothing else
 

DILLIGAF

Well-known member


Flamethrower on the lid, Caitlin Rose bottom lash line, and In the spotlight in the inner corner.


Flamethrower, in the spotlight, caitlin rose and showtime

Caitlin Rose is not a smooth shadow, it's actually... pretty bad lol I don't think I'll be using it again.
The others remind me of Stila magnificent shadows or whatever they are called, but easier to use and not creasy.
They look pretty stunning in person. Also liner doesn't go on as smooth on top of them, so sorry for my choppy liner.

What do u guys think?
Why can't I thumbs up this more!
 

mel33t

Well-known member
Flamethrower on the lid, Caitlin Rose bottom lash line, and In the spotlight in the inner corner.  Flamethrower, in the spotlight, caitlin rose and showtime Caitlin Rose is not a smooth shadow, it's actually... pretty bad lol I don't think I'll be using it again. The others remind me of Stila magnificent shadows or whatever they are called, but easier to use and not creasy. They look pretty stunning in person. Also liner doesn't go on as smooth on top of them, so sorry for my choppy liner.  What do u guys think?
Voltage can you come to my house to teach me how to do makeup? You have serious skills. Gorgeous on you !!! :stars:
 

Prettypackages

Well-known member
haha thank you! :)
I've thought of making tutorials but idk who would watch lol .

Thank you :)
I think what I meant is like.. it's not opaque because it wouldn't go on smooth lol..
it's not my favorite, but thank you!

Caitlin Rose is just dryer, harder to work with, my brush wouldn't pick it up :/

Thank you :)

That's the one thing I miss about working for Sephora, I used to love teaching clients how to do shadow or anything else... well and I loved the discount too hahah
you can just teach us then. LOL
 

v0ltagekid

Well-known member
you can just teach us then. LOL
I guess that's not a bad idea :)
I can try and record a tutorial, I've only ever done unboxings but that sounds fun.
I'll try a go at it tomorrow :) I may need a better camera lol

edit:
some girls actually recorded me at work lol, they brought their friend to record me so they could try to re do what i did later haha so there are vids of me somewhere teaching
 

DILLIGAF

Well-known member
I got my shadows today and Mesmerized it absolutely beautiful. So is Houdini but that one arrived shattered and fell out out the pan.
700
 

v0ltagekid

Well-known member
Makeup Geek Customer Service is amazing! They responded by 715am EST. They will be shipping out a replacement for my shattered shadow!
That's so nice of them :) yay!!!!
I've never had to contact them but I love how they always write something on my order confirmation so I love them haha
 

nt234

Well-known member
Makeup Geek Customer Service is amazing! They responded by 715am EST. They will be shipping out a replacement for my shattered shadow!
I just received my Houdini the other day and it was damaged as well... only about 25% percent of it is still in the eyeshadow pan. I sent an e-mail first thing Thursday morning and still haven't received anything. I'm hoping for a response later today!
 

DILLIGAF

Well-known member
I just received my Houdini the other day and it was damaged as well... only about 25% percent of it is still in the eyeshadow pan. I sent an e-mail first thing Thursday morning and still haven't received anything. I'm hoping for a response later today!
Did you sent the email from your own address or did you use their site? I used their site and that's why I think I got a quick response. My replacement arrived and it was also broken. However I was able to salvage it and put it in my palette. I did however send them an email about the softness of the product. Hopefully they will react and make a slight heartier formula. The color is STUNNING though. I think I'm going to get Flamethrower and Grandstand next.
 

nt234

Well-known member
Did you sent the email from your own address or did you use their site? I used their site and that's why I think I got a quick response. My replacement arrived and it was also broken. However I was able to salvage it and put it in my palette. I did however send them an email about the softness of the product. Hopefully they will react and make a slight heartier formula. The color is STUNNING though. I think I'm going to get Flamethrower and Grandstand next.
I used the email app on my phone. That makes sense. I finally got a response today and they are sending another one :) hopefully this one isn't as crushed as the original one. I'm so excited to try it out!
 

NotteRequiem

Well-known member
This is just in general, but I really love MUG eyeshadows. I'm just crazy about the range and color pigmentation!! Also, I do appreciate the little thank-you notes when you make an order. It personalizes the experience and Marlena clearly knows what she's doing.

I have most of the eyeshadows save for the Foiled ones. I'm going to wait a bit before I jump on them but I really hope this company continues to put out great and amazing things :)
 

Davuu

Member
And there's another foiled eyeshadow launch in April.
That's what I heard, I wish I knew, I only just ordered the ones that she released and shipping to the UK costs so much. :( Oh well, it's okay, I placed an order with ABH for a few of their single eye shadows so I'll see whether I REALLY need these ones. But let's be real, the make up addict in my will cave. :(
 
Top