I only bought utopia and salem before pansy and I am seriously thinking about gifting those two to family just so I can have the new formula with that delicious smell. It smells that damn good to me. And my utopia for some reason seems like its thickening or changing its consistency. I cant quite explain it but I don't get much product out of it when I dip into like I did when I first purchased it and it seems a little dry going on now. I haven't used it much, maybe twice. Whatever the case may be, I am determined to have all my velvetines smell like that yummy cake batter. Lol.