MAC X Toledo Collection (Feb 5, 2015)

[mel33t]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?
I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.

EDIT: never mind i found this!!
looks like they're exactly the same!

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg
Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

 

[MakeupQueen4]

I hope the blushes performs great for the price we pay since the packaging is already cheap

My thoughts exactly. I don't mind if a blush doesn't have a mirror but I truly think this packaging misses the mark. I had planned to get two blushes and two lipsticks but now I'm not so sure. I don't want to spend money on a great product (fingers crossed the blushes are great) with cheap packaging that I wont feel comfortable stashing with my other makeup let alone feel safe carrying it along for travel.

 

[Dolly Snow]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?
I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.

EDIT: never mind i found this!!
looks like they're exactly the same!

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg
Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

Ripe Peach is so darn pretty

 

[charismafulltv]

Ripe Peach is so darn pretty 

OMG! It's exactly the same they just change the names

 

[mel33t]

OMG! It's exactly the same they just change the names

Ah well... money saved I guess.

 

[cr8zy4MAC]

They're sneaky little buggers!

 

[Addict4MAC]

Yup! It's more aesthetically pleasing than a stark white plastic backing. In the alternative, the clear lid would at least let you see which colour you have storage-wise.


Quote: Originally Posted by Vineetha


I am not particular having a mirror with the Blush too but without one that particular design looks ummm incomplete is all!!

My thoughts exactly ladies.

 

[Addict4MAC]

They're sneaky little buggers!

This isn't the first time MAC has pulled this.

I don't have Ocean City so I guess I would be fine picking up Ripe Peach.

 

[do8666]

Oh! I am all over those ombre blushes for sure!

 

[Foxy2282]

Oh! I am all over those ombre blushes for sure!

Me Too!!!

 

[sungelly87]

I have ocean city. I don't really use it at all. I hope ripe peach has a better texture than ocean city...that was a basic disaster

 

[OctoberViolet]

Tx for the swatches of Ripe Peach. Since I already have Ocean City, I don't need another one.

 

[Lipstickwh0re]

I think I'm going for Ripe Peach blush, Oxblood lipstick and possibly another lipstick.
Totally off-topic but every time someone posts something about Clorafill I keep picturing this scene from Billy Madison.

NO I WILL NOT MAKE OUT WITH YOU! I'M TRYING TO LISTEN TO THIS GUY TALK ABOUT CHLOROPHYLL!

 

[thefbomb]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?
I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.

EDIT: never mind i found this!!
looks like they're exactly the same!

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg
Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

Hmm maybe I dont need Ripe Peach since I have Ocean City, Im also trying to save money. Thanks for posting this

 

[mel33t]

NO I WILL NOT MAKE OUT WITH YOU! I'M TRYING TO LISTEN TO THIS GUY TALK ABOUT CHLOROPHYLL! 

STOP STARING AT ME SWAN!

 

[Naynadine]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?
I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.

EDIT: never mind i found this!!
looks like they're exactly the same!

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg
Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

I didn't know they were that similar. Makes me feel a lot better about missing out on OC, although the Proenza packaging was much cooler than this one.

 

[Jennifae]

I have Ocean City. Why do I still want Ripe Peach? I know I don't need both. :sigh:

 

[MandyVanHook]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?
I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.

EDIT: never mind i found this!!
looks like they're exactly the same!

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg
Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

Umm... wow! If those aren't exactly the same, they are extremely close! It looks like the exact same blush just renamed.

 

[ILoveMakeup84]

Ripe Peach is so darn pretty 

Ripe Peach is amazing!! Love it so much!

 

[allthingsglam]

Does anyone have Ripe Peach and the Proenza blush from Ocean City they could swatch and compare?  I have Ocean City... I'm wondering if I need Ripe Peach.  EDIT: never mind i found this!!  looks like they're exactly the same! 

Blog post: http://cdn.cosmeticsanctuary.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Comparison.jpg Credit to Cosmetic Sanctuary

These two do look the same I have both I'm going to swatch them