She did say it was because if the gondola, but to me that's ridic if other stores got it together. This was Herald Sq for Pete's sake! She could have talked to the moon and back and I wouldn't have taken her seriously since I know she's the UD rep but my thing is, is Anastasia not waterproof? I like that aspect. Tbh I use Wet n Wild pencil, lol, works fine. I have a NYX Skinny but I think the color is too light, can't remember. I also have their brow marker. I tried Sephora's once and their darkest wasn't enough for me so I was going to buy either ABH, since I tried it on Thurs., or UD. Or get the darkest of NYX, ha! What do you use? As I was saying before, I change up every so often depending on how I want them to look between dramatic and natural. I think dramatic was a phase, I don't think it's really me.