MAC Enchanted Eve / Magic Of The Night / Irresistibly Charming Holiday Collection (Oct 18, 2015)

[Vandekamp]

It does, and their Copenhagen. Or JP Acai. Can't wait to compare!

I'll get the first Er by Thursday or Friday and the second one next week. I had hoped that it was more like Private Party.

 

[Vandekamp]

Evening Rendezvous looks different (lighter) in the tube. Once you swatch it, you can see the red, especially when it's more heavily swatched. It's pretty, though! I love the packaging.

Is it BU-worthy?

 

[leonah]

You should. I did. I got all of the lipsticks except Please Me.


Is it BU-worthy?

I wonder that too! in that case I rather have 2 ER than 1 ER and dark side or one of the other lipsticks that are perm

 

[slowlikehoney]

Sorry for the sloppy swatches.

Natural lighting

 

[montREALady]

Sorry for the sloppy swatches.

Natural lighting

Girrrrrl, you're on it! My new BFF! So yeah, Aria and Acai are similar but ER is a touch darker. Thanks!

 

[Vandekamp]

Sorry for the sloppy swatches.

Natural lighting

Awesome swatches. Thanks for doing this. There is a slight difference BUT not enough of one to justify a BU in my book. I am a bit disappointed. I kinda feel duped. In fact, I think Aria and Acai are prettier. Oh well. I am happy to have something in a purple bullet. However, that is not a reason to buy it tho. I have the Osbourne collection for that. Lol.

Damn it. Where is the purple??????????/

 

[Vandekamp]

Girrrrrl, you're on it! My new BFF! So yeah, Aria and Acai are similar but ER is a touch darker. Thanks!

Hey lady. What are you thoughts? I kinda feel misled. I think we all wanted to see more purple than red.

 

[montREALady]

Awesome swatches. Thanks for doing this. There is a slight difference BUT not enough of one to justify a BU in my book. I am a bit disappointed. I kinda feel duped. In fact, I think Aria and Acai are prettier. Oh well. I am happy to have something in a purple bullet. However, that is not a reason to buy it tho. I have the Osbourne collection for that. Lol.

Damn it. Where is the purple??????????/

It's a purple metallic bullet. Totally different. Plus KO collection was more of a lilac/lavender

 

[montREALady]

Hey lady. What are you thoughts. I kinda feel misled. I think we all wanted to see more purple than red.

Yup, but I'll wait to swatch it myself and look at it in person.

 

[Vandekamp]

It's a purple metallic bullet. Totally different. Plus KO collection was more of a lilac/lavender

Some of the earlier swatches made it look like it was more in the Private Party or Strong Woman family.

 

[LUVISLUV]

I'm curious as to why that is the case. Bloggers that were sent the collection ahead of time could only do hand or arm swatches. I've seen one lip swatch.

That is strange! Well I guess since the collection is repromotes and apparently reprobates with new names, lol. I am interested to see swatches from people that have WOG and Glorify against OD and SoG.

 

[montREALady]

Some of the earlier swatches made it look like it was more in the Private Party or Strong Woman family.

I don't have either, but I liked the swatches that made it look purple and close to a darker Dodgy Girl...

 

[montREALady]

If it is a dupe for JP Acai I will be excited I missed out on that one!
That is strange! Well I guess since the collection is repromotes and apparently reprobates with new names, lol. I am interested to see swatches from people that have WOG and Glorify against OD and SoG.

OMG, that one is LIFE! One of my favs and still different from Fashion Revival.

 

[Vandekamp]

If it is a dupe for JP Acai I will be excited I missed out on that one!
That is strange! Well I guess since the collection is repromotes and apparently reprobates with new names, lol. I am interested to see swatches from people that have WOG and Glorify against OD and SoG.

I know a lot of ladies are more interested in the highlighters. I was more interested in the lipsticks.

 

[Vandekamp]

OMG, that one is LIFE! One of my favs and still different from Fashion Revival.

I do love Acai. Fashion Revival did not excite me. I have Fashion Revival but I rarely use it. lol

 

[Vandekamp]

I wonder why Christine did not do a lip swatch of Evening Rendezvous? She only previewed the collection.

 

[Miss Dynamite]

I wonder why Christine did not do a lip swatch. She only previewed the collection.

She hasn't reviewed or swatched the lipsticks at all yet. But she posted lip swatches of the mini Cremesheen Glass sets.

 

[Miradan]

She hasn't reviewed or swatched the lipsticks at all yet. But she posted lip swatches of the mini Cremesheen Glass sets.

I swear I keep checking her swatch gallery every hour or two to see if she's put anything up. In the meantime, just gave in and ordered ER anyhow.

 

[Vandekamp]

She hasn't reviewed or swatched the lipsticks at all yet. But she posted lip swatches of the mini Cremesheen Glass sets.

I only saw one lip swatch out there and it looked more purple than red. I guess I will have to wait and see if my opinion changes when I get my delivery.

 

[laurennnxox]

That swatch makes me wanna order ER!!! :eyelove: I don't know. I have (and never reach for JP Acai) so not sure if I really should pick it up or not...