montREALady
Well-known member
Girl I stay wearing NYX liners! I have like 15+ and 2 MAC ones, lol. They are an exact match pretty much.
MAC Enchanted Eve / Magic Of The Night / Irresistibly Charming Holiday Collection (Oct 18, 2015)
- Thread starter Naynadine
- Start date
Vandekamp
Well-known member
I will try that combo today if i don't like ER with the mac magenta liner. I have 4-5 NYX liners, about 75 Mac lip liners and 50 Colorpop lip liners.
Vineetha
Well-known member
I was checking to see if they have the pick up in store option live!! I called and phone ordered buddy !!
KGeezy
Well-known member
welp, true to my flakey self, I stopped by Macy's and caved lmao. I ended up getting OD and ER. there were 2 other girls waiting with me and they wanted to get 5 ODs each (!!!) but the SA shut them down real quick lol. only one per customer. I take back everything I said about ER, it's def not a heroine dupe like I thought it would be. it's definitely a darker version of MLM . I haven't had a chance to swatch OD yet but here's ER. NC 42 for reference . excuse the crappy lighting , I took it on the fly just before work
mstiffanynicol
Active member
Vandekamp
Well-known member
Very pretty. Glad to hear that you think it's a darker version of Men Love Mystery,
Vandekamp
Well-known member
Nice swatch. Thanks for posting. Do you see it as being one of your favorite purples? Is it unique?
msvluvsmac
Well-known member
I just got OD. I was so disappointed about Nordies cancelling my order so I was going to skip but after I saw all of the swatches here, I decided to just try and call the store near me to see if they had any left. They had 2 left and I snagged 1.
msvluvsmac
Well-known member
Pretty! Love that color on you.
SerenLuv
Well-known member
I got to Macys about 5 minutes after they opened. I was able to get OD, SOG with no problems. Only 1 other person at the counter and she was getting 2 OD and 1 SOG. The SA did say that they got limited stock on both. I ordered SOG from Nordies yesterday too and it already shipped. I love the how SOG looks on me.
Vandekamp
Well-known member
I just got OD. I was so disappointed about Nordies cancelling my order so I was going to skip but after I saw all of the swatches here, I decided to just try and call the store near me to see if they had any left. They had 2 left and I snagged 1.
Vandekamp
Well-known member
montREALady
Well-known member
Went to Macy's Herald Sq and got my sis an OD. There were only 2 left in the drawer, 1 after me. I get to the cash and there are a ton put aside. Different people because they are sorted by name. Some have 3 each. I don't know that they are for actual clients because their names are on laminated cards. Employees? I wasn't planning to get it anymore because she said she'd wait but I got it just in case. So I kinda was lucky I went when I did.
mstiffanynicol
Active member
The one on the left is the pink from the pink lip bag. I think it's very pretty. It leans a little lavender. I have ER also at home I don't find it to be unique. I have some comparison swatches that I will post.
starletta8
Well-known member
I just dragged my sick butt out of bed for three things: more food (I'm out), more drugs (same), and MAC. While some may only think 2 are essentials, I'll rank them all the same. I was first in line at my local store and snagged the 2 things that I wanted, plus one more that called to me while I was peering at the display through the gate for 15 min: Oh Darling, Please Me, and the Essential basic brush kit.
I have the Cool Face Palette arriving today- I couldn't help it after seeing Karen's review a couple of weeks ago.
I have the Cool Face Palette arriving today- I couldn't help it after seeing Karen's review a couple of weeks ago.
LiliV
Well-known member
I love the highlighter!Low and behold I think I like SoG more! Or maybe both equally?Here are swatches of both. Near the window and the one from last night:
Wearing SoG. I used my Real Techniques Setting Brush and it was perfect.
Near window. All highlighters seem to look the same in pics though. Lips: NYX Intense Butter Gloss in Chocolate Crepe Blush: Clinique Cola Pop
Sweetyellow
Well-known member
I went out to my local Macy's this morning and I got to swatch OD just to see if I'd like it in-person and unfortunately it's too frosty and glittery for me. I have seen people refer to it being a cream/powder hybrid and honestly from the swatches I did...SoG is definitely better in that regard. I really don't get all the fuss about OD, I personally don't like it. Also, it's been 30 minutes since I've come back and the swatch on my hand of OD is completely gone (except for some glitter) whereas SoG is still there. I don't know but OD seems to disintegrate after some time and just plain glitter is left behind. Odd.
Rinstar
Well-known member
Went to Macy's this AM- I got there at 9:54 and was in right away when the doors opened, so I had no trouble grabbing OD. I also caved and got the nude lip bag, oops!
Are any of you the beautiful WOC I talked to this morning at the CT Post Mall Macy's in Milford CT? I swear we need a Specktra code word when we think someone else is a Specktrette!
The SA was telling her to skip OD and just get SOG, but she ended up grabbing both. I could tell she really wanted OD, so I was glad she stuck to her guns.
And now I'm going to go slather myself in gold shimmery goodness
Are any of you the beautiful WOC I talked to this morning at the CT Post Mall Macy's in Milford CT? I swear we need a Specktra code word when we think someone else is a Specktrette!
The SA was telling her to skip OD and just get SOG, but she ended up grabbing both. I could tell she really wanted OD, so I was glad she stuck to her guns.
And now I'm going to go slather myself in gold shimmery goodness
