I was absolutely shocked to see these palettes in my Sephora this morning since they're incredibly slow now at putting out new product. I swatched them all and I feel like Spirit is the best for me across the board It's not the most exciting palette, but some of the lighter shades in the other palette don't seem like they'll work out for me. The Body palette seems more exciting than it actually looks in real life. The packaging is really nice and I wasn't even aware they have a mascara with the collection. It all looks impressive, but I'm not going to buy Spirit right now. I don't wear shadow nearly enough these days and I have so much of it. I just wanted to know which palette would be best for me and now I know.