I like UDPP the best. Does anyone have any suggestions for oily lids? My 20 year-old daughter has very oily skin (my 'gift' to her, I'm afraid) and she can't wear eyeliner because they all smudge horribly on her (UD 24/7, Tarte SmoulderEyes, MAC f/l). She's tried UDPP, TFSI and Benefits Stay Don't Stray; none of them work.
Right now she's having the most luck with MAC Paint Pots as a base under powder shadows, but she skips the liner. I've heard good things about NARS, but I don't know if it's really much better for oily lids. Does anyone else have this problem? If so, what do you use?