I'm personally unsure on how I feel about the CP highlighter. I think it all depends on your preference/comfort zone, but I found it to be quite flashy and reflect a lot of light on my dark skin. It definitely comes off metallic on my skin. I blended the little I had on into my skin as much as possible, and went over it with the new CT Dreamy Glow highlighter-- now that highlighter is subtle, but not so much so that your skin won't be glowing. It really does mimic a soft, dreamy effect on the skin, without highlighting skin imperfections, and although it appears light, it will NOT come off chalky or ashy on deep complexions. I just hate that it's so pricey! But I do love it already.
I will have to play with CP a little more before I come to a conclusion as to whether or not it's for ME. I've always liked softer highlighters though, so others may LOVE this.