Best / Worst candidate for MAC ICON?

[Lolita]

oh man, Debby harry would be amazing!... but I dunno, she was gorgeous in the 70's and 80's, but I think her lifestyle has caught up with her, shes really showing her age :S but then again, I guess Liza is definitley a victim of that too. yikes.

Im torn on Christina. I'm not really a fan, but I think mac would be able to come up with some really creative, interesting and unique stuff for her. And like everybody else, I hate mariah, but I think I would probably like a collection inspired by her (im thinking warm shimmery neutrals, mmmm)

 

[jamiemeng]

Best:Gwen Stefani and maybe Dolly Parton
worst:Whitney Houston and Christina Aguilera.

 

[blepharisma]

They could do a group ICON set, with a punky edge... and combine Siouxie Sioux, Debbie Harry & Joan Jett.

That would be so hot.

They'd have to market lots of dark eyeliner with that group!

 

[Coco_Hailey]

I totally agree for Siouxie Sioux, Debbie Harry & Joan Jett, that would kick a**

and I prefer Madonna over Cher

Gwen is still young to be an icon, but she'd be great for VivaGlam

 

[missunderstood]

I think Gwen Stefani would be awesome. Maybe even Janet Jackson. J.Lo isn't quite an icon yet, but she would probably inspire some great colors. I think Cher would get a bit crazy, but it would be interesting to see what her collection would be.

 

[wolfmaster]

Best Icon- Madonna, i think Gwen and JLo can definately make it there
Worst: no comments...

 

[Bubbles]

I'd like to see Dolly Parton.. or someone who wears pale lip colours because MAC needs more.

Worst: Michael Jackson

 

[KIT]

GWEN!!!! She is my all time favorite.
Also I think Janet Jackson would be great. She got a great toned body and killer cheek bones.

 

[beautifulxdisaster]

oprah winfrey, haha.

and all the others ppl mentioned.

I REALLY like the debbie harry idea.

no offense to her but the worst would be...


Tammy Faye.

 

[V2LUCKY]

I figured out a worst....................... Joan Rivers ugh that lady is so ugly

I can't stand her!

 

[beautifulxdisaster]

lmao I just thought of another worst.


Jocelyn Wildenstein

 

[V2LUCKY]

I found some great pics of Cher to show you guys why MAC should use her in the next icon collection

 

[dianella]

I love the Cher and Dolly ideas. I agree that Tori Amos would be really awesome too. She could inspire some GORGEOUS makeup. I humbly submit the ideas of Brigitte Bardot, that could be a really hot collection.

Worst? Jennifer Lopez (Ugh, I can't stand that woman), Britney Spears (especially latey, she's a train wreck) Anna Nicole Smith, and WORD on the Donatella Versace nom. She's scary looking, with the orange, oompa loompa skin and platinum hair.

 

[mrsdivajen]

How awesome would Tori Amos be? She is SO beautiful and such a strong woman...Gwen Stefani is great too...

 

[Coco_Hailey]

Quote:

Originally Posted by dianella ... I humbly submit the ideas of Brigitte Bardot, that could be a really hot collection. Worst? Jennifer Lopez (Ugh, I can't stand that woman), Britney Spears (especially latey, she's a train wreck) Anna Nicole Smith, and WORD on the Donatella Versace nom. She's scary looking, with the orange, oompa loompa skin and platinum hair.

I totally agree about Brigitte Bardot, she'd be a great MAC ICON!
I also think that Donatella Versace would be a horrible candidate!
She always looks so oily to me, when I see pics of her I always wonder if it's actually her or a wax replica! I'm also not a fan of Jennifer Lopez, she's almost on the hasbeen list, but that's just my opinion!

 

[midnightlouise]

hmmm....I love Gwen, but I think it would be hard for older MAC fans to identify with her as an Icon. I think Cher, Tina, and Dolly are all great choices. Most of the younger ladies mentioned will be fabulous someday! And I think my pick would be somebody like Patty Smyth, Debbie Harry or Marianne Faithful. I know their lifestyles have caught up with them, but I saw a recent pic of Diana, and that postcard was *seriously* retouched lol!

 

[little_angel]

i love the dolly parton idea.. she's amazing. also, oprah would be great. she's an incredible woman.

i think isabella rosellini would make a beautiful icon as well.


however, i'll probably catch hell for this, but i really don't care. i can't stand gwen stefani. she was my first thought for who i think shouldn't be one.

before i'm attacked for my opinion, remember it's just that... my opinion.

 

[MACgirl]

i think our icon 08 should be one of these fabulous ladies:
cher, maddona, patti labelle, sophia loren, brigette bardot, dolly parton, oprah winfrey, pat benetar, cyndi lauper, meryl streep

 

[user79]

Quote:

Originally Posted by V2LUCKY Cher would be the GREATEST! I would LOVE to see a collection with her. Now for the worst hmmmmm.......... maybe........I can't think of any right now I'll have to get back to you.

I thought of her too but she's a mix between best AND worst icon! Haha...Her style is so weird.




Worst MAC Icon: Paris Hilton

and Michael Jackson haha

 

[Indigowaters]

My vote would be for Mary J. Blige. She's already a Viva Glam diva and with 8 Grammy nominations this year, she's well on her way to icon status.