I have quite a few MAC blushes in a bunch of different colors. I recommend having a couple, just to match different looks and everything. My favorite ones are Blooming from Cult of Cherry (a light pink), Dollymix (it looks BRIGHT pink but it goes on like a natural flush), Hipness (from Fafi, if you can find it I'd REALLY recommend it. It's a light peachy color). If you do get a mineralize, I'd definitely get Petticoat. That's the one I have, and I have dark hair and eyes like you. It's REALLY pretty, a golden rose color, and it looks really pretty on. It can be used as a highlight color or alone, as a blush. It was my first MAC blush and I've used almost all of it.