It did suck. I was all excited to get some bronzers made for darker skin and that one made me almost not try the others. It was BAD. Now, Rum Spice is a great shade if you like the shimmer, and Gingersnap isn't awful, but Blackberry...ooh. I notice it is no longer on the Black Radiance site - maybe they are going to revamp or replace?Ohhhhh....that sucks. I don't own either one but the swatches I saw looked like a good dupe. Hopefully, she'll find the metal rock especially if the BR looks ashy.