Its not new or old packaging, its the bundle kid from www.toofaced.com
Here is a link to the different style tube. Also if it has been sitting a while the thin drippy stuff will come out first, take it by the lid and shake it around and squish it up. Just needs to be remixed sometimes like nail polish. Also the older it is, the darker it may become.
https://www.toofaced.com/p-548-shadow-insurance-policy-eye-shadow-collection.aspx?