Third on Woodwinked, a great staple to have, it's a warm rusty gold colour that goes with just about everything, and since you like neutrals I think you'd like this one. It's also a veluxe pearl so the consistency is great!
Since you have blue eyes, orange shades would look GREAT on you, so I would also suggest Expensive Pink. It's a warm peachy golden orange shade that is subtle with just enough colour.
Mulch, as already stated, is also nice, it's a warm brown tone with gold shimmer in it, but it's also pretty close to Tempting so I'm not sure if it's absolutely necessary.
Coppering is also gorgeous, a very vibrant coppery red shade, and it's also a VP so great pigmentation and easy to blend. Can also be applied lightly and it looks amazing with Melon pigment or with Woodwinked.