NW25: Wow, I have tons of pink lipsticks, so this is a hard question for me to answer. I would say the one that I find myself always coming back to is Angel.
Some others worth mentioning:
- A Rose Romance: Just got this one from a user here. It reminds me a bit of angel but it is more moist, and has a golden sheen. I have worn it with Starlet Kiss lipglass (from yet another user here) and it's the perfect girly pink lip. Too bad it is limited edition.
- Snob: A tinge of lavender, paired with Docile lipglass (from Fabulous Felines) and I have a pinky-purple lip that is wearable and doesn't make me look dead
- Saint Germain: A little hard to pull off sometimes, I wear it when I want something a bit over the top. Looks great with a tan.
Others I have are Lazy Day(LE), Strayin'(LE), Politely Pink, VG Gaga, Girl About Town, Show Orchid, Lovelorn, Hue. Victorian(LE) probably qualifies too.
I don't really wear the dark pinks very often. Kind of a shame, really.