Good non waterproof smudge resistant mascara? Am I asking too much??

[kariii]

i second the l'oreal voluminous. I've tried every mascara out there but I always go back to this one. it's the BEST. and for 6 bucks? Can't beat that!

 

[gigiopolis]

Try tube-y mascara. You're asking the right girl here. Every possible kind of mascara smudges on me, no matter how waterproof it is (there are some exceptions of course, but they're a bitch to remove!)

I've recently tried Clinique Lash Power mascara. It's water resistant and smudge-proof, only comes off with warm water and a bit of pressure. Fiber-wig mascara has the same sort of idea, but I don't like it as much. There's also the new L'Oreal Double Extend Beauty Tubes mascara that also utilises the same concept.

 

[amyzon]

I love love LOVE Maybelline Define a Lash. It's my lover, srsly.

 

[User38]

eek! I have tried thousands of mascara over the years.. I always go back to L'Oreal.. either the voluminous or the Extend... plain old is the best, imo

one hint: usually the more expensive, the less bang you get for the buck..lol