I completely agree with you! I'm NW45 in MAC's Studio Fix Foundation and I wore Champagne Pop for the first time last night and I absolutely love it. I was initially a little bit hesitant when I was putting it on because of what people were saying about it possibly looking ashy on darker skin tones, but that definitely was not the case for me. To be honest, I'm a bit miffed that people who don't have certain skin tones and have no experience working with certain skin tones, would make those comments, possibly deterring people away from purchasing a product without having any knowledge of how it even looks on said skin tone. That's why, sometimes it's good to just try something for yourself first, especially if you have the ability to try it on in store or can return it if you don't like it if it's a product you're really interested in.