Has anyone tried Cremestick Liner by M.A.C.?

[poddygirl]

I have the Cream O Spice liner and love it. The lip pencils were sometimes too dry for me but these are really nice and long-lasting. Highly recommend (and I need to get more!)

 

[MAC_Whore]

OK, dusting off this old thread with the release of the new Cremestick colours. I am pleased with the colours. There are some nice (needed) new shades.

Cremesticks are nice in that they are more moisturizing and definitely stay on longer (esp with P+P), but I gotta admit though, I really like being able to use a regular lip pencil that I can sharpen fairly well. I feel like you get a cleaner line around the edge of the lip. Sure you have to blend it in a bit, whereas you don't have to blend so much with the creamsticks, but cremesticks look kind of sloppy at the edge of the lips IMO.

What are your thoughts on the cremesticks?

 

[jenii]

I like them. They're not as drying as the regular liners. I have Pink Treat and 80%, and I have to say those are the two lipliners I use most often.

I don't have the problem of them looking sloppy around the edges of my lips, though.

 

[~LadyLocks~]

I only own one and I love it!! It glides on!

 

[Winthrop44]

I like them. I agree that the colors could be better -- and I'm hoping they will be with the addition of these new ones -- but I love the feel of them going on. I love Subculture but the cremesticks feel so much more comfortable to apply that 9 times out of 10 I reach for Sublime Culture instead.

 

[Cruella]

I love the Cremestick liners. The other lip liners were so dry & hard that I felt like my lips were going to get rubbed off.