R&R jeans are hot! That said, I really like #1.
a) they're dark wash, which is a plus for me. Can wear it during the day & switch to night time effortlessly w/ just a change of top.
b) the stitching on the back is screaming rocker chic.
c) material & quality wise, #1 is the better option. I do not like the pleather material on #2's belt loop & pocket. It's tacky, IMO. If it's rhinestones, like what they put on regular R&R's then it's a different story ha ha.
d) the cut looks more versatile, at least to me. I can see wearing #1 with boots one day and slinky heels another. With #2, I can only see it paired with heels. HTHS!