Home-made Smoked Eyes palette: shadow subs

[Laurahead108]

I'm mixing up a Smoked Eyes palette, and want to use what I have to dupe the shades in the original palette. I'm missing Malt and Grey Fume, and would love some recommendations:

Can I use Knight Devine to sub for GF? If not, what shadow might work?
Can I use either Arena or All That Glitters to sub for Malt?

Thanks for your help, all of you wise enough to get the palette when it came out.

 

[Sparklevixen81]

ooh i just did this myself! You could maybe try era(it is a bit darker than malt though) for malt, and via a live chat I had with a mac MA, she suggested print as a sub for GF, hope this helps!

 

[prinzessin784]

Very cool idea!! I'm also interested to see other's suggestions!

 

[Sparklevixen81]

laurahead108...i missed out on the pallete too but i wasn't as bummed when i heard that 5 of the colors were permanent! and you can always substitute shades if the exact ones from the pallete aren't to your liking or whatever, have fun!