ummm...how about the good old hug me(mac)?? It's be gorgeous on you...!!Also, have you tried midimauve...jubilee or high tea for a pretty neutral?? politely pink is very light, but looks nice on your skin tone...
and now, speaking of non-mac...do check out the new Colour Riche made for me naturals by Loreal...in 8 new shades i think...very natural..very pretty...
you would surely be able to see something that looks good on you...
hope that helps!!
you're pretty cute...by the way