Hello again!
I am a LUSH mask fanatic, in fact, I have The Sacred Truth on right now. I'm half afraid it might make me break out, but, it smells nice and feels quite soothing, so, I'll risk it
I also LOVE the Mask of Magnaminty (my general all-purpose favourite) with Cosmetic Warrior being my beloved for when my skin is misbehaving. It smells awful, but, works wonderfully.
Cupcake, something about the smell makes me completely sick to my stomach. It also itched terribly. I feel sad about that as it seems to be the favourite of many people.
Ayesha and Love Lettuce are also kickass, I use the two interchangeably and are very close to the Magnaminty. If they are in stock at my local LUSH, I get one of those instead of it.
Hmm, this is probably not helping... I usually have 2-3 LUSH masks around at a given time!
If I had to choose 2 for the rest of time... I guess it would be Mask of Magnaminty and Cosmetic Warrior. HTH!