By Candlelight is about the same in terms of peachy pinkness, maybe more tan-peach but WAY more golden sheen. Of course, depends on your veining but just my opinion. I really like PP, but sometimes its a bit too warm for my desires, of course then I switch to Perfect Topping MSF (wish they would repromo that!) or Play It Proper BP. PP is unique though and it has its uses. I won't back it up, but I keep it and love it.
I wish I could love Stereo Rose, but just not pretty on me. Northern Lights and Light Flush take my votes as favorite old school metallic MSF highlighter/blushies. I think I like the more subtle new MSF formula much better. I am NC20 for reference and more like NC16 or maybe NW16 in the winter...wind and cold bring out my pink
Love in vein?
I think I am on a brown kick and so grateful we have color story. Winter Pursuit and Alpine Bronze sound up my alley. Of course when this comes out, I will be too pale to enjoy the latter for a few months, except maybe as a contour.